Peer Review Rubric

Meets or Exceeds Established Assignment Criteria

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

An introduction with a clear thesis statement

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations.

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Project includes all required topics:

Community Organization, Community Partnerships, Cross-Cultural Challenges, Humanitarian Considerations, Volunteers, Roadblocks, Future Vision, Challenges, and Improvements

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations.

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Meets project presentation requirements:

·        Paper – 5-7 pages

·        Presentation - 8-10 minutes presentation including visual elements (graphics, pictures, etc.), 150-200 notes per slide, and recorded voice

·        Speech - 8-10 minutes and a written script of the narrative

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations.

 

Clearly Presents Well-Reasoned Ideas and Concepts

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Evidence supporting claims cited throughout the project

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations.

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Used a minimum of 10 reputable sources

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations. 

 

Quality of Project

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Academic and professional tone and appearance

15

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations. 

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Grammar and proofreading

10

Fill in

 

Provide feedback for your score in this category here. Why did you take points off or why did you provide full points?  Include constructive (positive) comments and recommendations. 

 

Conclusion

 

Grading Criteria

Possible Points

Points Awarded

Total 

100

Fill in

 

Provide an overall conclusion and impression of your peer’s paper.  What did your peer do right? What could they improve?  This should include recommendations and constructive comments to help your peer improve.